Format & Prices

You’re enjoying a fabulous buffet meal and then the intrigue heightens around dessert time, where you meet some colourful characters. The plot thickens when somebody dies! A detective leads the investigation. The suspects are spread throughout the room, sitting right at the tables with the guests. So, you get to participate and see if you can solve…WHODUNIT?! (Prizes are awarded to some of the guests with the correct solution.)

Guests celebrating Birthdays or Anniversaries can be included in the mystery. Be sure to mention the celebration when booking.

Saturday Evenings

(Prices are for our regularly scheduled public shows, and do not apply to private mysteries.)

Mystery Evenings:

Arrival for Buffet Dinner: 6:30 pm
Mystery begins: 7:45 pm

and continues to about 9:45 PM

Click here for Chelsea Hotel Buffet Menu

Mystery Matinees:

on select Wednesdays at the Old Mill Inn
See Calendar

Arrival for Buffet Lunch at: 11:30 am
Mystery begins: 12:30 pm

and continues to about 2:30 PM

Click here for Lunch Menu

Regular Prices: Saturday at Chelsea Hotel, Toronto
Dinner & Show:* $119

Prices are per person in Canadian funds.

*Dinner & Show price includes coffee or tea. Tax & gratuity included.

Soft drinks and alcohol are extra (CASH BAR). Coat Check extra.

Regular Prices: Wednesday at The Old Mill Inn
Show Tickets:** $37
Lunch & Show:*** $69

Prices are per person in Canadian funds.

*Show price includes 13% HST.

***Lunch & Show price includes coffee or tea. Tax & gratuity included.

Soft drinks and alcohol are extra. Coat Check extra.

Promotions & Special Offers

Seniors (65+) and Full-Time Students: $5.00 discount from regular prices. Discounts also available for Groups of 10 or more.
(Discounts cannot be combined, are subject to limited availability of discounted seats and may not apply on some dates.
Must specify discount offer at time of booking.)

Reservations can be made by phone. Full payment is processed at time of reservations. We have a Five Day Cancellation Policy. Reservations can be cancelled until 5 days in advance of the performance date, at 5:00 pm to receive a full refund.

Weather Policy. We are committed to honouring our performance schedule. All performances proceed as scheduled despite weather conditions and traffic delays . If travelling in inclement weather, please allow for extra time and check TTC for delays and updates. We regret that tickets not used due to inclement weather, traffic delays, or TTC closures cannot be refunded or exchanged.

* Must specify Web Site Special Offer at time of booking.
* Package Prices shown on this page are per person for Dinner & Mystery, including Tax & Gratuity.
* Valid only for above mentioned performances. Offer is subject to restrictions and limited availability of discounted seats. Offer cannot be combined with any other discount or special offer. Offer cannot be applied to existing reservations.
Prices and details are subject to change without notice.
We reserve the right to cancel this offer at any time.

Date Special Offer Mystery
Saturday, October 13th 2018 Almost Sold Out!  Limited seats available. No Time to Kill! (A Time-Travelling Mystery)
Date Special Offer Mystery
Saturday, October 27th, 2018 Join us for Halloween weekend at our new location at the Chelsea Hotel.  Dress in Halloween Costume – Prize awarded for Best Costume!  No Time to Kill! (A Time-Travelling Mystery)
Date Special Offer Mystery
Saturday, year-round Students / Seniors receive $5 off per person No Time to Kill! (A Time-Travelling Mystery)


Gift Certificates

Mysteriously Yours…Gift Certificates
Gift Certificates are available in any denomination and can be purchased by phone.

One or more Gift Certificates can be applied toward an evening (or matinee) at Mysteriously Yours Dinner Theatre!

We can e-mail them to you and you can print them on your printer or we can mail them to you (or directly to the recipient).
The recipient then calls to make a reservation for a date that is convenient for them.
(Reservations are subject to availability)

Call For Details and Reservations

or purchase tickets online at


 Gift Certificates are available!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This